Google clarified its new AI policy for K-12 schools after backlash from educators and parents. The company said schools can disable Gemini apps while keeping search active, or disable all AI features including search entirely. Schools cannot access search without AI tools.
Under the new policy, schools using Google apps must opt into AI products. Google bundles search with its AI portfolio, which includes Gemini, Gemini Notebook, Gemini in Classroom, and Search with AI Overviews and AI Mode.
A Google spokesperson told Ars Technica the company has not changed the policy announced this week. The company's approach gives schools the choice to block all AI while retaining other Google apps, but does not offer AI-free search.
Google steadfastly refuses to create a toggle to turn off AI in search because it sees AI as the future of search. A Google VP for education told The New York Times the company developed its new approach to give schools more control. Early reporting suggested Google would block search access for schools rejecting AI, but the company clarified schools can make that decision based on their internal policies.
Schools currently can block the Gemini app, but AI tools in search remain active. Under the new system, schools choosing which AI features to use will see search as one option. Google offers a Guided Learning version that won't give away answers as readily, according to the company's claim.
Educators who want students to search the Internet without AI tools cannot do so with Google. Switching to another provider is difficult because Google has the most expansive index of the Internet. However, following Google's loss in the DOJ's search antitrust case, the company must provide competitors limited access to its web index, which could improve alternatives.