The FCC voted yesterday to allow state and local prisons to use jamming technology to block contraband cellphones, despite warnings from the wireless industry that the jammers will interfere with legitimate communications outside prison walls.

CTIA, the wireless industry lobby, conducted a pilot test with Virginia Tech Applied Research Corporation and the South Carolina Department of Corrections. The test showed the jamming system blocked 911 calls and caused interference up to two and a half miles away. CTIA told the FCC in an October 1 filing that the technology is "both over and underinclusive at once" because it blocks lawful communications while failing to jam a significant portion of targeted devices, with outdoor testing showing failure rates of one-half to two-thirds of call attempts.

FCC Chairman Brendan Carr said facilities will apply to the FCC to deploy jamming, explain their deployment plans, and demonstrate through testing that it stays within the designated area. Communities nearby will receive notice before operations start. Carr said contraband phones continue to enter prisons by the thousands each year, with estimates indicating 500,000 inmates nationwide have regular access to these devices.

Commissioner Anna Gomez, the only Democrat on the three-member commission, voted to allow jamming after safeguards were added but said she is concerned about unintended consequences and that families of incarcerated people should not pay for jamming costs through higher calling service rates.

Freedom of the Press Foundation Chief of Advocacy Seth Stern opposed the order, noting that contraband phones have been used to document abuses inside prisons. He cited the Oscar-nominated film "The Alabama Solution," which used footage captured on contraband cellphones to expose conditions in state prisons and bolster a DOJ investigation.

Prison phone companies ViaPath and NCIC Correctional Services supported the order, as did the National District Attorneys Association, the Correctional Leaders Association, and the National Association of Police Organizations. CTIA has argued in court filings that the FCC has no authority to allow jamming under the Communications Act, which directs the FCC to prevent interference.